WPCZ 2m ZB.HP DeskJet 895C Series PrinterX\  PG;Pa1114Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers8@   a2114Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersA@` `  ` ` ` a3114Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersJ@  ` `  2La4114Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersS@  a5114Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers\  @hh# hhh a6114Right-Aligned Paragraph Numberse  @( hh# a7114Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersn @- ( 2  q  q~a8114Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersw@pp2 -ppp a1AgendaAgenda Items %*  a2AgendaAgenda Items a3AgendaAgenda Items 2 q! qq qt a4AgendaAgenda Items a5AgendaAgenda Items a6AgendaAgenda Itemsa7AgendaAgenda Items2Y q    a8AgendaAgenda Items a1113Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers8!"@   a2113Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersA#$@` `  ` ` ` a3113Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersJ%&@  ` `  2u 8  a4113Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersS'(@  a5113Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers\)*@hh# hhh a6113Right-Aligned Paragraph Numberse+,@( hh# a7113Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersn-.@- ( 2zxua8113Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersw/0@pp2 -ppp a1Order"12a2Order+34a3Order4562Y 3=a4Order78 I. A. 1. 1.(1)(a) i) a)a5OrderP9: a6Order[;< a7Orderf=> 27 !U"#a8Order q?@ a1DocumentDocument Style!FAB *  ׃  a2DocumentDocument Style"*C D   a3DocumentDocument Style#0E F    2$pi%e&e>'pa4DocumentDocument Style$GH . a5DocumentDocument Style% IJ a6DocumentDocument Style& KL a7DocumentDocument Style'MN` ` ` 2(pE)*e+a8DocumentDocument Style(OP` ` ` a1TechnicalTechnical Document Style)4Q!R     a2TechnicalTechnical Document Style**ST    a3TechnicalTechnical Document Style+'UV    2,-\./da4TechnicalTechnical Document Style,&WX    a5TechnicalTechnical Document Style-&YZ  . a6TechnicalTechnical Document Style.&[\  . a7TechnicalTechnical Document Style/&]^  . 2"0q1!2p!a8TechnicalTechnical Document Style0&_`  .  1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P#X0Í ÍX0Í Í12footnote reference1ab112Document Style2cd` ` ` 2$3e7"4e"5q#6r#111Document Style3 ef 110Document Style4 gh 109Document Style5i j . 108Document Style60k l    2'79$8$9%:W&107Document Style7*mn   106Document Style8Fop *  ׃  105Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers9wqr@pp2 -ppp 104Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers:nst@- ( 2*;Q'<(=(>s)103Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers;euv@( hh# 102Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers<\wx@hh# hhh 101Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers=Syz@  100Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers>J{|@  ` `  2,?I*@*Av+B+99Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers?A}~@` `  ` ` ` 98Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers@8@   97Technical Document StyleA&  . 96Technical Document StyleB&  . 2.C,D7-E-FP.95Technical Document StyleC&  . 94Technical Document StyleD&  . 93Technical Document StyleE&   92Technical Document StyleF'   21G/H/Ipc0J091Technical Document StyleG*    90Technical Document StyleH4$     89Document StyleI` ` ` 88Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersJw@pp2 -ppp 24K1L2M]3N487Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersKn@- ( 86Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersLe@( hh# 85Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersM\@hh# hhh 84Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersNS@  27O4P5QP6R!783Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersOJ@  ` `  82Document StylePF *  ׃  81Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersQw@pp2 -ppp 80Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersRn@- ( 2:S8T8U9V=:79Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersSe@( hh# 78Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersT\@hh# hhh 77Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersUS@  76Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersVJ@  ` `  2J=W;X;Y@<Z<75Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersWA@` `  ` ` ` 74Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersX8@   73Technical Document StyleY&  . 72Technical Document StyleZ&  . 2?[|=\>]>^?71Technical Document Style[&  . 70Technical Document Style\&  . 69Technical Document Style]&   68Technical Document Style^'   2nB_?`}@ap-AbA67Technical Document Style_*    66Technical Document Style`4$     65Document Stylea` ` ` 64Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersbw@pp2 -ppp 2EcBdhCe'DfD63Right-Aligned Paragraph Numberscn@- ( 62Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersde@( hh# 61Right-Aligned Paragraph Numberse\@hh# hhh 60Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersfS@  2HgEh`Fi1GjG59Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersgJ@  ` `  58Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbershw@pp2 -ppp 57Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersin@- ( 56Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersje@( hh# 2KkHlImMJnJ55Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersk\@hh# hhh 54Right-Aligned Paragraph NumberslS@  53Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersmJ@  ` `  52Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersnA@` `  ` ` ` 2MoKpPLqLrZM51Right-Aligned Paragraph Numberso8@   50Technical Document Stylep&  . 49Technical Document Styleq&  . 48Technical Document Styler&  . 2[PsNtNu*OvO47Technical Document Styles&  . 46Technical Document Stylet&   45Technical Document Styleu'   44Technical Document Stylev*    2SwPxp=QyQz~R43Technical Document Stylew4$     42Document Stylex` ` ` 41Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersyw@pp2 -ppp 40Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersz8@   2W{ BS|FNT}U~Vannotation tannotation text{ZP annotation rannotation reference|ww#Xv P7XP##Xv P 7XP#Format DownlFormat Downloaded Document} XX #P!#  #X\  P"G;P# \ #d6X@#C@#CitatorFormat Secretary's Citator Output File~#d6X@$C@# XX  \X b#d6X@%C@# XX *  b2^hW8Z\]header2 `    #FxX  P&CXP# `   #FxX  P'CXP#itemize*  XF r#FxX  P(CXP# FF r#FxX  P)CXP#reference;'#FxX  P*CXP##FxX  P+CXP#39Technical Document Style&  . 2`6^^k__38Technical Document Style&  . 37Technical Document Style4$     36Technical Document Style&     35Technical Document Style'     2&c`baalb34Technical Document Style*     33Technical Document Style&  . 32Technical Document Style&  . 31Document StyleF *  ׃  2ffXc)dde30Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersw@pp2 -ppp 29Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbersn@- ( 28Right-Aligned Paragraph Numberse@( hh# 27Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers\@hh# hhh 2ifEgg~h26Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersS@  25Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersJ @  ` `  24Document Style0! "    23Right-Aligned Paragraph NumbersA#$@` `  ` ` ` 2EkKipiMjej22Right-Aligned Paragraph Numbers8%&@   21Document Style'(` ` ` 20Document Style*)*   19Document Style +, 2=mewkqkpMll18Document Style -. 17Document Style/ 0 . 16Document Style12` ` ` 15_Equation Caption342;som<m1p<p14endnote reference56QuoteQuote78` p x (#` p x (#page numberpage number;9;:#Xx6X@,QX@##Xj\  P-G;XP#Indent 1Indent 1;< ` p x (#X` hp x (#2)zms<u3x+yIndent .5Indent .5=> ` p x (##Xx6X@.QX@##Xj\  P/G;XP#X` hp x (#13footnote text?@ ` p x (#X` hp x (#11_Equation CaptionPAPB10endnote referenceSCSD2}[zS{{d|9Default Paragraph FontPEPF8'GH'#d6X@0C@##d6X@1C@#7SIJA, B,Uppercase Letters KL.2sZQ}}S~d1, 2, 3,NumbersMN1._Equation Ca_Equation Caption(O(Pcaptioncaption2Q(R toa headingtoa headingST (#` hp x (#25dd dmdшindex 2index 2UV ` (#`` hp x (#index 1index 1WX ` (#` hp x (#toc 9toc 9YZ (#`` hp x (#toc 8toc 8[\ (# ` hp x (#2Ogd#ddtoc 7toc 72](^ toc 6toc 6_` (# ` hp x (#toc 5toc 5ab h(#` hp x (#toc 4toc 4cd  (#` hp x (#2[dddItoc 3toc 3ef ` (#` hp x (#toc 2toc 2gh ` (#`` hp x (#toc 1toc 1ij (#`` hp x (#endnote refeendnote reference+k+l2iIendnote textendnote text2m(n 6Default Paragraph Font(o(pheading 8heading 82q(r heading 7heading 72s(t 2uWϠheading 6heading 62u(v heading 5heading 52w(x heading 4heading 42y(z 5'{|'#d6X@2C@##d6X@3C@#2 _para numnumbered indented paragraphs}'~ 1.#Xj\  P4G;XP# 1.Ҳfootnote ref+footnote tex2head1'#2p5C #2RU D uF Default ParaDefault Paragraph Font;;#Xj\  P6G;XP##X\  P7G;P#UpdateInitial Codes for Update Module#)a [ P8QXP# dn  F#  [ b, oT9 !#)a [ P9QXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> Xi:QXX#` "Legal WordPerfect 5.0 Update Class Learning Guide   #)a [ P;QXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> Xi<QXX#Legal WordPerfect 5.0 Update Class Learning Guide   v#)a [ P=QXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> Xi>QXX#   Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988` APage  v#)a [ P?QXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> Xi@QXX#   Page `1 &Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 Style 9Initial Codes for Intermediate#)a [ PAQXP# dn  ## b, oT9 Њ [ #)a [ PBQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiCQXX#`e %Intermediate Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   #)a [ PDQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiEQXX#Intermediate Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   #)a [ PFQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiGQXX#   Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc.` APage  #)a [ PHQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiIQXX#   Page `1 &Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 Style 8Initial Codes for Beginning#)a [ PJQXP# dn  ## b, oT9  [ #)a [ PKQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiLQXX#`) &Beginning Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   #)a [ PMQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiNQXX#Beginning Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   #)a [ POQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiPQXX#   Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988` APage  #)a [ PQQXP# ## b, oT9 #)^ `> XiRQXX#   Page `1 &Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 2iF 1wStyle 10Initial Codes for Advanced#)a [ PSQXP# dn  ##  [ b, oT9 !#)a [ PTQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XiUQXX#`M 'Advanced Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   #)a [ PVQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XiWQXX#Advanced Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   v#)a [ PXQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XiYQXX#   Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988` APage  v#)a [ PZQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> Xi[QXX#   Page `1 &Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 Style 6Dutch Roman 14 Point''#w [ P\QP##)a [ P]QXP#Style 7Swiss 11.5''#)ao> P^QXP##)a [ P_QXP#Style 5Dutch Bold 18 Point''#T~> p`Qp##)a [ PaQXP#2sHStyle 2Dutch Italic 11.5'#)^ `> XibQXX#Style 1Dutch Roman 11.5 Font7#)a [ PcQXP# dn Style 4Swiss 8 Point with MarginsG#Co> PdQP# dd  #  Style 3Dutch Roman 11.5 with Margins/Tabs#)a [ PeQXP# n   # b, oT9 !2| ~X$Style 11Initial Codes for Advanced IIϓ #)a [ PfQXP# dn  ##  [ b, oT9 !#)a [ PgQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XihQXX#` %Advanced Legal WordPerfect II Learning Guide   #)a [ PiQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XijQXX#Advanced Legal WordPerfect II Learning Guide   v#)a [ PkQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XilQXX#   Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988` APage  : 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PmG;&P##)a [ PnQXP# ## b, oT9 !#)^ `> XioQXX#   Page `1 &Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 Style 12Dutch Italics 11.5''#)^ `> XipQXX##)a [ PqQXP#Style 14Swiss 8 Pt Without Margins''#Co> PrQP##)a [ PsQXP#32X[[&MACNormalENVELOPEStandard Business Envelope with Headerm V,  #  , 8'   ' `   VERY LARGEVery Large TypestyleEXTRA LARGEExtra Large Typestyle2[[[iXLARGELarge TypestyleFINEFine TypestyleSMALLSmall TypestyleNORMALReturn to Normal Typestyle2`N<<OINVOICE HEADHeading Portion of Math Invoice"   X 9@ 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PtG;&P# XX  *$  ӧ   XX @ 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)Ҳ#&a\  PuG;&P# XX  *$INVOICE TOTTotals Invoice for Math Macro Xp, $0INVOICE EXPExpense Subtotals for Math Invoice p,p, $0MEMORANDUMMemo Page Format޹  D* M E M O R A N D U M ă y<dddy 2<IjndINVOICE FEEFee Amount for Math Invoice p,, $0  LETTERHEADLetterhead - date/margins!  X  3'   * 3' II Ѓ    X HIGHLIGHT 3Large, Italicized and Underscored  HIGHLIGHT 2Large and Bold 2inXXnHEADING 33rd Heading Level BLOCK QUOTESmall, single-spaced, indented FOOTERFooter A - AppearanceTITLETitle of a Document* ă2cPcccyLEGAL PORTLegal Portrait - 8.5 x 14  A' II   LETTER PORTLetter Portrait - 8.5 x 11  3' II   LEGAL LANDLegal Landscape - 14 x 8.5  'A II   LETTER LANDLetter Landscape - 11 x 8.5  '3 II   2XfdHEADERHeader A - AppearanceDRAFT OFFTurn Draft Style off*  DRAFT ONHeader A Text = DRAFT and DateB X 8$@ 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PvG;&P#`$ .DDRAFTă `.C 3 1, 4   $HIGHLIGHT 1Italics and Bold 2=^v FOOTNOTEFootnote - AppearanceSubheadingSubheading.   Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbers<@    HeadingChapter Heading3  *  ׃  2sopeRBullet ListIndented Bullet List` ` ` Heading 1Centered Heading* Ã  Heading 2Underlined Heading Flush Left PleadingHeader for Numbered Pleading Paperx   XX* 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PwG;&P# ,X  y*dddyy*dddy H\1 H\2 H\3 H\4 H\5 H\6 H\7 H\8 H\9 H10 H11 H12 H13 H14 H15 H16 H17 H18 H19 H20 H21 H22 H23 H24 H25 H26 H27 H28   X2nDoc InitInitialize Document Style    I. 1. A. a.(1)(a) i) a)DocumentҲTech InitInitialize Technical Style 1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 TechnicalBibliogrphyBibliography Body Text 2HH#Xj\  PxG;XP##Xj\  PyG;XP#2"_Paragraph[8]1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)q Paragraph[7]1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)f Paragraph[6]1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)[ Paragraph[5]1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)P` ` ` hhh 2XZ:0QParagraph[4]1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)E` ` `  X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&Xj\  PG;XP%\  `&Times New RomanX&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  P G;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  P G;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  P G;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  P G;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  P G;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New Roman&a\  PG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&X\  PG;P%\  `&Times New RomanXv P7XP) `*Times New Roman (TT)XXv P 7XP) `*Times New Roman (TT)XP!X\  P"G;P%\  `&Times New Romand6X@#C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)d6X@$C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)d6X@%C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)FxX  P&CXP*X   `*Times New Roman (TT)XFxX  P'CXP*X   `*Times New Roman (TT)XFxX  P(CXP*X   `*Times New Roman (TT)XFxX  P)CXP*X   `*Times New Roman (TT)XFxX  P*CXP*X   `*Times New Roman (TT)XFxX  P+CXP*X   `*Times New Roman (TT)XXx6X@,QX@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)XXj\  P-G;XP%\  `&Times New RomanXXx6X@.QX@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)XXj\  P/G;XP%\  `&Times New RomanXd6X@0C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)d6X@1C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)d6X@2C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)d6X@3C@<6X9`("Courier New (TT)Xj\  P4G;XP%\  `&Times New RomanX2p5C 22AArial Bold (TT) Xj\  P6G;XP%\  `&Times New RomanXX\  P7G;P%\  `&Times New Roman)a [ P8QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)a [ P9QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> Xi:QXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ P;QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> Xi<QXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ P=QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> Xi>QXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ P?QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> Xi@QXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PAQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)a [ PBQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiCQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PDQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiEQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PFQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiGQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PHQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiIQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PJQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)a [ PKQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiLQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PMQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiNQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ POQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiPQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PQQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiRQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PSQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)a [ PTQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiUQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PVQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiWQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PXQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XiYQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PZQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> Xi[QXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)Xw [ P\QP$ [  `*Times New Roman (TT))a [ P]QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)ao> P^QXP)o> A`Arial (TT)X)a [ P_QXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)XT~> p`Qp#~>  *Times New Roman (TT))a [ PaQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XibQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PcQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)XCo> PdQP*o> A`Arial (TT))a [ PeQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)a [ PfQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)a [ PgQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XihQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PiQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XijQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PkQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XilQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X&a\  PmG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&)a [ PnQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X)^ `> XioQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)^ `> XipQXX! `>  `6Times New Roman Italic (TT)X)a [ PqQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)XCo> PrQP*o> A`Arial (TT))a [ PsQXP" [  `*Times New Roman (TT)X&a\  PtG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&&a\  PuG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&&a\  PvG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&&a\  PwG;&P%\  `&Times New Roman&Xj\  PxG;XP%\  `&Times New RomanXXj\  PyG;XP%\  `&Times New RomanX2ZZ3|a X   #Xj\  PG;XP#ъ   DISSENTING STATEMENT OF COMMISSIONER HAROLD FURCHTGOTT-ROTH   Re:Commonwealth of Virginia State Corporation Commission v. MCI Telecommunications Corporation (File No. E9901).  I respectfully dissent from today's decision to allow carriers to recover federal schools and libraries charges based on an enduser's intrastate calls. 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эThe majority opinion describes the assessment on intrastate revenue as supporting "various Universal Service mechanisms." Memorandum Opinion and Order, at par. 7. For purposes of assessing contributions to the high cost and low income support mechanisms, however, the Commission assesses based on interstate revenue only. Universal Service Order, 12 FCC Rcd 8776, 9200. Moreover, currently the Commission does not assess any revenue to support the rural health care program. See Second Quarter 1999 Universal Service Contribution Factor Public Notice (rel. March 4, 1999). Thus, contrary to the majority's description, the only program that is supported through assessments on intrastate revenue is the schools and libraries program.  I believe that basing a percentage surcharge on customers' intrastate calls cannot be considered recovery "through rates for interstate services only," as required by the Commission itself.e 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эUniversal Service Order, 12 FCC Rcd 8776, 919091, 9198, 920304 (1997).e Today's decision from which I dissent, however, finds that under current FCC orders it is appropriate and reasonable for a carrier to charge a federal percentage surcharge based on a customer's intrastate calling, and that such a practice does not impact the "charges" for intrastate calls that are properly under state commission jurisdiction. In contrast, I believe that such a practice does impact intrastate calls, and therefore is properly within a state's jurisdiction. Moreover, since the Commission noticeably fails to rely explicitly on the fact that MCI did not impose a surcharge on customers who made no interstate calls in a given month, the Commission signals its openness to the possibility that this "federal" surcharge could even be placed on customers where no interstate usage at all is involved. Let me illustrate. Under the logic of today's decision, an MCI customer who lives in Richmond and makes $100 worth of calls to Norfolk can be assessed a federal schools and libraries tax or, euphemistically, a "fee" based on this intrastate revenue, regardless of the fact that he places only one 1 minute call across state lines at the dimeaminute rate of $.10. Assuming a 5% contribution rate, that customer would owe a "federal" charge of $5.01: 5% x $100 intrastate and 5% x $.10 interstate. In effect, the Commission allows for a "federal" interstate charge and a "federal" intrastate charge. In fact the majority's analysis would not change at all if MCI's surcharge had been explicitly broken into two components: a Federal Interstate Universal Service Charge, and a Federal Intrastate Universal Service Charge. I cannot support a decision that determines, under these facts, (i) that a carrier is not recovering universal service charges through intrastate services, and (ii) that the Commission is not impacting intrastate "charges" in violation of Section 2(b). Today's decision demonstrates the fallacy of the Commission's argument that its assessment for the schools and libraries program based on intrastate revenues does not violate Section 2(b). As I have described on several occasions, the legality of this approach to calculating contributions is highly questionable.D 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#э  Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the FederalState Joint Board Report to Congress, rel. April 10, 1998; Separate Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the Second Quarter 1998 Universal Service Contribution Factors, rel. March 20, 1998.D As I read the Communications Act, it does not permit the Commission to assess contributions for universal service support mechanisms based on intrastate revenues, and I have repeatedly objected to this approach. I believe, rather, that the Act makes clear that the power to collect charges based on such revenues rests within the exclusive province of the States. Section 2(b) of the Communications Act creates a system of dual federalstate regulation for telecommunications. In essence, the Act establishes federal authority over interstate communications services while protecting state jurisdiction over intrastate services. I believe that the Commission's decision to look to intrastate revenues to determine federal universal service support for the schools and libraries program impermissibly encroaches on states' rights and violates the Act's federalstate dichotomy. Indeed, as I have discussed on numerous occasions, the Commission's actions in this regard and in many other ways as well violate the clear directives of the Telecommunications Act and are illegal. 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  P G;&P##X\  P G;P#эSee, e.g., Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the FederalState Joint Board Report to Congress, rel. April 10, 1998. See also, Testimony of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding Universal Service before the Ways and Means Committee of the House of Representatives; Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding Federal State Joint Board on Universal Service, CC Docket 9645, Third Order on Reconsideration, 12 FCC Rcd 22801 (1997); Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the Second Quarter 1998 Universal Service Contribution Factors, rel. March 20, 1998; Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the Report to Congress in Response to Senate Bill 1768 and Conference Report on H.R. 3579, rel. May 8, 1998; Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the Common Carrier Bureau's Proposed Revisions of 1998 Collection Amounts For Schools and Libraries and Rural Health Care Universal Service Support Mechanisms, rel. May 13, 1998; Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the Common Carrier Bureau's Clarification of "Services" Eligible for Discounts to Schools and Libraries, rel. June 11, 1998; Statement of Commissioner Harold FurchtgottRoth Regarding the Common Carrier Bureau's Third Quarter 1998 Universal Service Contribution Factors, rel. June 12, 1998. Perhaps most importantly, however, today's decision undermines several of the arguments advanced by the Commission in defense of its universal service rules before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. First, in that litigation, the Commission argued that its actions did not violate Section 2(b) because it did not "regulate" intrastate telecommunications services.` 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  P G;&P##X\  P G;P#эFCC Brief in Texas Office of Public Utility Counsel v. FCC, at 184.` But Section 2(b) actually bars the Commission from any jurisdiction with respect to "charges, classifications, practices, services, facilities or regulations for or in connection with intrastate communication service . . . " 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  P G;&P##X\  PG;P#э47 U.S.C. Section 152(b). See also Louisiana PSC v. FCC, 476 U.S. 355, 359 (1986) ("[T]he Act grants to the FCC the authority to regulate 'interstate and foreign commerce in wire and radio communication' while expressly denying that agency 'jurisdiction with respect to . . . intrastate communications service.") (internal citations omitted).  I find it unfathomable that the Commission can uphold a federal charge based on intrastate calling as it does today, but still claim that it is not asserting jurisdiction over "charges, classifications, [or] practices . . . for or in connection with intrastate communication service."7 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#э47 U.S.C. Section 152(b). 7 The fact that this charge is filed in the form of a federal tariff does not convert what is essentially a charge "for or in connection with intrastate communication service" into an interstate charge. Indeed, in this Order, it is striking that the Commission fails even to explain why MCI "could reasonable have concluded that the methodolgy for recovering universal service contributions at issue here fell within the directive of the Universal Service Order."G 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эMemorandum Opinion and Order, at par. 20. G Second, the Commission argued to the Fifth Circuit that it has not violated Section 2(b) because, "[a]s the FCC has made clear, contributing carriers under this system must recover their contributions solely through interstate rates."`  1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эFCC Brief in Texas Office of Public Utility Counsel v. FCC, at 185.` In the decision today, however, the Commission determines that this very same language is not quite so clear. Indeed, it determines that the language is ambiguous enough for a carrier to base the level of its federal schools and libraries charge to end users on the level of intrastate communications.G  1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эMemorandum Opinion and Order, at par. 20. G In other words, what is now "clear" is that by "interstate rates," the Commission meant that a carrier could charge an "interstate" rate based on the number and quantity of "intrastate calls." Indeed, the Commission does not even remove the possibility that such an "interstate rate" could include a charge placed on a consumer who makes no interstate calls whatsoever. Now that the Commission is really being "clear" about what can and cannot be done, I do not understand how it can continue to assert that it is not impacting intrastate communication services or intrastate rates that are outside of its jurisdiction. Third, the Commission argued that the [P]etitioners do[] not explain how the assessment of federal charges can constitute regulation of intrastate services when those charges can only be recovered through interstate rates. Since [petitioners] ha[ve] failed to demonstrate how the challenged contribution system 'regulates' intrastate service, the court should reject the company's claim that the system violates section 2(b).`  1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эFCC Brief in Texas Office of Public Utility Counsel v. FCC, at 186.` Certainly, with today's order, the Commission itself demonstrates how its scheme regulates intrastate services since the " inter state rates" of which the Commission speaks are actually rates that are based on  intra state service usage. In fact, the Commission determines that such a recovery scheme was fully "within the directive of the Universal Service Order."G  1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эMemorandum Opinion and Order, at par. 20. G To demonstrate the absurdity of the Commission's position, I take it out of the federal versus state framework. Suppose that a power or gas company, regulated by FERC and the relevant state authorities, entered the telecommunications market. The Commission's position would be analogous to claiming that it could base universal service contributions on that company's total revenue, including both its telecommunications and power or gas revenues. Under today's decision, moreover, the telecommunications subsidiary of the power company could also place a universal service surcharge on its end users based not only on that customers telecommunications revenues, but also based as a percentage of that customers power or gas usage. It seems absurd that the Commission could argue that such an action would not constitute either a charge or regulation of gas or power. Yet, the Commission seems to be arguing that it has the authority to enact such a scheme under the Telecommunications Act, claiming jurisdiction over power revenues merely because a power company's customer also availed themselves of that company's telecommunications service offering. I do not believe that Congress intended to provide such broad jurisdictional authority to the FCC. In addition, I would note the Commission has scrupulously avoided relying too closely on MCI's practice of not charging customers who have no intrastate calls in finding no violation here.J  1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#эMemorandum Opinion and Order, at par. 1920. J The Commission has not wanted to rely too heavily on this fact because many carriers are recovering from customers through enduser charges regardless of whether any interstate calls are made. By failing to explicitly rely on this fact, however, the Commission has opened the door to upholding a "federal" universal service charge on customers who have no interstate calls whatsoever. In conclusion, I note that some might ask why is it so important for the Commission to be able to assess based on intrastate revenues for the schools and libraries program? Why is it necessary to continue these legal gymnastics and absurdities just to preserve the ability to assess a carrier's intrastate revenues as well as its interstate revenues? The answer is that the contribution base more than doubles when intrastate revenues are included. 1. 1. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a)#&a\  PG;&P##X\  PG;P#э Second Quarter 1999 Universal Service Contribution Factor Public Notice (rel. March 4, 1999) (interstate only contribution base is $18.305 billion, while interstate and intrastate contribution base is $48.843 billion). And it is much easier to place a new tax on a broader base because the effects that will be felt are much smaller. Thus, the inclusion of intrastate revenues makes new charges harder for consumers to find and easier for consumers to swallow. I fear that some here at the Commission may view intrastate revenue as a yet untapped source of revenue for the funding of their new and additional programs.112HHHH