WPC 2MB ZCG Times (Scalable)CG Times Bold (Scalable)CG Times Bold Italic (Scalable)3|_HP LaserJet IIISi - NetworkHPLAS3SI.PRSXN\  PH!XPX01Í ÍX0ÍÍ 2%0f< XN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX P7XP(`  Z (CG Times RegularXXN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXXN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXXN\  P XP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX*0 x 7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x 7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x 7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x 7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXXN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXXN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX P7XP(`  Z (CG Times RegularXXN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXX*0 x7X* `(CG TimesScalableXXN\  PXP(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularX"m+O6^;C]ddCCCdCCCCddddddddddCCȲY~~wCN~sk~CCCddCYdYdYCdd88d8ddddJN8ddddYYdYddddddCddddddddd8YYYYYY~Y~Y~Y~YC8C8C8C8ddddddddddYdddddsdYYYYYYYd~Y~Y~Y~YddddddddC8C8C8C8oNd~8~8~8~8~8dvddddJJJkNkNkNkN~8~8~8dddddddYYYd~8dJkN~8dddddCddCCCWxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxNdddCYQQddddddFddddFCChhd44ddzzdddwooChdF"Ȑdhd岲dCCȐzȲxCddodȐȅdCdYdsȐ]ȐȐȧzȐUwŐdȐYYCCCCѐz~ozoY~NYdYC8YooYdYzsdzdd~YYzozzzzNd88YYYzYzzzzCCdddddddzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzNNNNNNNdddddddddddddddddddd888888888888YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzCs~CzCddYC"m+O6^;C]ddCCCdCCCCddddddddddCCȲdzN`zoȐCCCddCdoYoYFdo8Co8odooYNCodddYdddddddddCddddddddo8dddddϐYYYYYN8N8N8N8oddddooooddoddddzodddYYYYoYYYYddddddooN8N8N8N8r`o888N8ooodd┐YYYoNoNoNoNCCCooooooȐdYYYo8oYoNCddodoCddCCCWxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxNdddCdUUddddddFddddFCCssd44ddzzddd~ooCsdF"Ȑdsd岲dCCȐzȲxCddodȐȅdCdYdsȐ`ȐȐȮzȐUwŐdȐddCCCCѐzozoYNYYYN8YooYdYzzdzddYYzozzzzNY88YYYzYzzzzCCdddddddzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzNNNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY888888888888YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzCzNzNddYC"m+O6^;NhddCCCdCCCCddddddddddCCȲdzNdzzozzzCCCddCddYdYFdo88d8odddNN8oYdYNdddddddddCddddddddd8dddddYYYYYN8N8N8N8oddddoooozYddddzYdzddddYYYYdYYYYddddddooN8N8N8N8kddz8z8z8zFz8oooddהNNNoNoNoNoNz8z8z8oooooozYzNzNzNdz8oNoNz8zYzYddoCddCCCWxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxNdddNdYYddddddCddddCCCkkd88ddzzdddsssCkdC"Ȑd~d岲dCCȐzȲxCddodȐȅdCdYdsȐ`ȐȐȮzȐUwŐdȐddCCCCхzozoYNzYYYN8YooYdYzzdzddzYzYzozzzzNY88YYYzYzzzzCCdddddddzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzNNNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY888888888888YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzCzNzzNzddYC21D%*Z.J1"m+O6^$/><><q*"xxxxWWxxxWWkkxxxa݅@  I.   X(# BibliogrphyBibliography݅X  (# SubheadingSubheading0\ E A.  Default Para|6_ 8 o9L=(:V*:TAnjE1'#A\  PP##Xw P7XP#2~;z446O6 O/9Page Number|6_ 8 o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE'#A\  PP#,JR Z bj ##Xw P7XP#Footnote Ref|6_ b o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE**#A\  PP##Xw P7XP#Headern|6_ p o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE!(##Xw P7XP# R Z bj ##Xw P7XP#Footern |6_ ~ o9F=(:nd V*:TAnjE  !(##Xw P 7XP# R Z bj ##Xw P 7XP#2 F ; > O+A zCQuestionn |6_  o9F=(:nd V*:TAnjE G     d  d ` hp x (# #Xw P 7XP#      ,JR Z bj ##Xw P 7XP# answern |6_  o9F=(:nd V*:TAnjE $   ` hp x (# #Xw P 7XP#    ,JR Z bj ##Xw P7XP#Footnote Tex|6_  o9F=(:nd V*:TAnjE 4 <DL!T$#A\  PP# 4 <DL!(##Xw P7XP#Body Text |6_  o9F=(:nd V*:TAnjE     d 4` hp x (##&R2P&P#    ,JR Z bj ##Xw P7XP#2O;FHJHMList Bullet|6_  o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjEP   #Xw P7XP#    ,JR Z bj ##Xw P7XP#Heading 4|6_  o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjEI   ` hp x (##Xw P7XP#   ,JR Z bj ##x P7P#Heading 5|6_  o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE   4` hp x (##x P7P#    ,JR Z bj ##x P7P# Heading 6|6_   o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE   4` hp x (##x P7P#   ,JR Z bj ##x P7P#2PXPRUWHeading 7|6_  o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE   4` hp x (##x P7P#   ,JR Z bj ##x P7P#Heading 8|6_ & o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE   4` hp x (##x P7P#   ,JR Z bj ##x P7P#Heading 9|6_ 4 o9F=(:ndV*:TAnjE   4` hp x (##x P7P#   ,JR Z bj ##x P 7P#Word4095NullWord4095Null11#Xd PT6UP##Xx PT6UXP#2\X=(?8*?$a2OutlineE+?OFI. A. 1. a. (1) (a) i) a)>=(?8*?/` ` ` a3OutlineE+?OFI. A. 1. a. (1) (a) i) a)>=(?8*?:` ` `  2=(?8*?E` ` ` a5OutlineE+?OFI. A. 1. a. (1) (a) i) a)>=(?8*?P ` ` ` hhha6OutlineE+?OFI. A. 1. a. (1) (a) i) a)>=(?8*? [ ` ` ` hhha7OutlineE+?OFI. A. 1. a. (1) (a) i) a)>=(?8*?!f  2cg"nb#d8c$Xf%ofa8OutlineE+?OFI. A. 1. a. (1) (a) i) a)>=(?8*?"q PleadingHeader for numbered pleading paper# xq     8 ` p   y,d dddyy, dddyy,h& dddy 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 *  MACNormal$,.Footnote%Íč2 n&Xg'g(h)-i1&dfStyle 14Swiss 8 Pt Without Margins'$$D Co> PfQ  )a [ PfQO Style 12Dutch Italics 11.5($$F )^ `> XifQ  )a [ PfQO Style 11Initial Codes for Advanced II)J )a [ PfQK  dddn  #  [ X` hp x (#%'b, oT9 ! )^ `> XifQ ` Advanced Legal WordPerfect II Learning Guide   x )^ `> XifQ Advanced Legal WordPerfect II Learning Guide   j-n )^ `> XifQ    Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988`6 >Page  jBX )^ `> XifQ    Page ` Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 2Nq*l>n+o,Fp-|pStyle 3oDutch Roman 11.5 with Margins/Tabs* )a [ PfQO  ddn  # c0*b, oT9 !Style 4 PSwiss 8 Point with Margins+Dq Co> PfQ  dddd  #  Style 1.5Dutch Roman 11.5 Font,4h )a [ PfQO  dddn Style 2Dutch Italic 11.5-$ )^ `> XifQ 2gx.q/ r0r1`sStyle 5Dutch Bold 18 Point.$RH$L T~> pfQ_  )a [ PfQO Style 7Swiss 11.5/$$V )ao> PfQ ]  )a [ PfQO Style 6Dutch Roman 14 Point0$$N w [ PfQ   )a [ PfQO Style 10oInitial Codes for Advanced1 U )a [ PfQK  dddn  ##  [[ b, oT9 !b, oT9 !n )^ `> XifQ ` Advanced Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   f )^ `> XifQ Advanced Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   Q" )^ `> XifQ    Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988`6 >Page  QN~ )^ `> XifQ    Page ` Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 2"2x3}45gStyle 8PfInitial Codes for Beginningg2i )a [ PfQK  dddn  # X` hp x (#%'b, oT9  [ &e )^ `> XifQ ` Beginning Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   d )^ `> XifQ Beginning Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   jH )^ `> XifQ    Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988`6 >Page  j )^ `> XifQ    Page ` Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 Style 9Initial Codes for Intermediate3 )a [ PfQK  dddn  # X` hp x (#%'b, oT9 Њ [ e )^ `> XifQ ` Intermediate Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   3 )^ `> XifQ Intermediate Legal WordPerfect Learning Guide   jf )^ `> XifQ    Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc.`+ >Page  jX )^ `> XifQ    Page ` Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 UpdateInitial Codes for Update Module4 )a [ PfQK  dddn  #  [ X` hp x (#%'b, oT9 !n )^ `> XifQ ` Legal WordPerfect 5.0 Update Class Learning Guide   f )^ `> XifQ Legal WordPerfect 5.0 Update Class Learning Guide   Q" )^ `> XifQ    Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988`7 CPage  jN~ )^ `> XifQ    Page ` Copyright  Portola Systems, Inc. 1987, 1988 "K|π 6 Small Circle(gw'Pھ=(B*B⾇K|πE5"2،6T7$8Ћ9XQuickFormat1X6w f6"=(6 pj 2*60W?@ Aa2Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`>=` `  a3Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`?:` ` `  a4Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`@E` ` ` a5Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`AP` ` ` hhh28BCJDEgѓa6Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`B[` ` ` hhha7Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`Cf ` ` ` hhha8Paragraph+9rPt1. a. i. (1) (a) (i) 1) a)9R=(9 kD ?b*9`Dq!"` ` ` hhhppp 2[13M'Square ' ' 5D15պcg51HDM' ޺g51MLq1E2ĖFjGHXƕI5B5_ـFootnote ReferenceB5M B5B5B5B5 [MF*]*^#c P7P##Xw P7XP#6B5aـFootnote TextZ B5M B5B5B5B5 [MG1_'`#c P7P##Xw P7XP#7B5b'ـaB5Z B5M B5B5B5B5 [MHab8B5cMـDefault Paragraph Font5M B5B5B5B5 [MI'c'd#Xd PTUP##Xw P7XP#2JKLaRM9B5d}ـFootnote ReferenceB5M B5B5B5B5 [MJ*e*f#Xd PTUP##Xw P7XP#10B5eـFootnote TextZ B5M B5B5B5B5 [MK1g'h#Xd PTUP##Xw P7XP#CHLETiـChicago Office LetterheadM @5@5@5@5 [ML #Z\  PP#S#XN\  PXP#IDLEY#Z\  PP# & A#XN\  PXP#USTIN`(#C#Z\  PP#C#XN\  PXP#HICAGOheading 1ـheading 1)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[MMYO#Xw P7XP##C\  PQP#2NOPQheading 2Dـheading 2)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[MNYO#Xw P7XP##C\  PQP#heading 3ـheading 3)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[MOYO#Xw P 7XP##C\  P QP#endnote textـendnote text<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[MPY#O$#Xw P7XP##C\  PQP#endnote refeـendnote reference)<M )<)<)<)<[MQR%R&#Xw P7XP##C\  PQP#2RS TUa1)#Xw P/7XP##C\  P0QP#Paragraph 6ـParagraph 6)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[M\O?O@#Xw P17XP##C\  P2QP#Paragraph 7ـParagraph 7)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[M]OAOB#Xw P37XP##C\  P4QP#2^1_'`ϮawParagraph 8ـParagraph 8)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[M^OCOD#Xw P57XP##C\  P6QP#toc 1/gBـtoc 1a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[M_-E#F(#`#Xw P77XP##C\  P8QP#` hp x (#toc 20,Dـtoc 2a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[M`-G#H` (#`#Xw P97XP##C\  P:QP#` hp x (#toc 31Eـtoc 3a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Ma-I#J` (##Xw P;7XP##C\  P<QP#` hp x (#2IbQcdeItoc 42Gـtoc 4a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mb-K#L (##Xw P=7XP##C\  P>QP#` hp x (#toc 53Iـtoc 5a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mc-M#Nh(##Xw P?7XP##C\  P@QP#` hp x (#toc 64IKـtoc 6a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Md-O#P(# #Xw PA7XP##C\  PBQP#` hp x (#toc 75Mـtoc 7a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[MeYQOR#Xw PC7XP##C\  PDQP#2f{g#histoc 86Nـtoc 8a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mf-S#T(# #Xw PE7XP##C\  PFQP#` hp x (#toc 97LPـtoc 9a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mg-U#V(#`#Xw PG7XP##C\  PHQP#` hp x (#index 1Rـindex 1a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mh-W#X` (##Xw PI7XP##C\  PJQP#` hp x (#index 2Sـindex 2a)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mi-Y#Z` (#`#Xw PK7XP##C\  PLQP#` hp x (#2jMkltoa headingـtoa heading)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[Mj-[#\(##Xw PM7XP##C\  PNQP#` hp x (#captionWـcaptiona)<Z )<M )<)<)<)<[MkY]O^#Xw PO7XP##C\  PPQP#_Equation Caـ_Equation Caption)<M )<)<)<)<[MlO_O`#Xw PQ7XP##C\  PRQP# Y  @0 Before the %FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION *Washington, D.C. 20554 In the Matter of %hh,28) ` `  %hh,28) Second Application by BellSouthhh,28) Corporation, BellSouth Telecommunications,8)pp?CC Docket No. 98121 Inc., and BellSouth Long Distance,28) Inc., for Provision of Inregionhh,28) InterLATA Services in Louisianahh,28)  Y  & MOTION OF AT&T CORP. TO STRIKE  X  "PORTIONS OF BELLSOUTH'S REPLY EVIDENCE ă ` ` AT&T Corp. ("AT&T") respectfully submits this motion to strike portions of  Yd the reply evidence submitted by BellSouth Corp. et al. ("BellSouth") on August 28, 1998.d Y ЍExhibit 1 to this motion lists the improper material submitted by BellSouth. In its reply brief and affidavits, BellSouth has once again submitted postapplication evidence  Y in violation of the Commission's rules for section 271 applications.y Y2 ЍThis Commission has previously and repeatedly held, both in establishing and enforcing procedural requirements for section 271 applications, that "'a section 271 application, as originally filed, will include all of the factual evidence on which the applicant would have the Commission rely in making findings thereon.'" Order, In the Matter of Application by Ameritech Michigan Pursuant to Section 271 of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, to provide InRegion, InterLATA Services in Michigan (CC Docket No. 971),  22 (February 7, 1997) ("Feb. 7 Order"), quoting Procedures For Bell Operating Company Applications Under New Section 271 Of The Communications Act, Public Notice at 2, FCC 96469 (rel. Dec. 6, 1996) ("Public Notice") (emphasis supplied by Commission in Feb. 7 Order); see also Application by Ameritech Michigan Pursuant to Section 271 of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, to provide InRegion, InterLATA Services in Michigan,CC Docket No. 97137, Memorandum Opinion and Order, FCC 97298 (rel. Aug. 19, 1997) ( Ameritech Michigan Order)  4959; Application of BellSouth Corporation, et al. Pursuant to Section 271 of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, to Provide InRegion, InterLATA Services in South Carolina, CC Docket No. 97208, Memorandum Opinion and Order, FCC 97418 (rel. Dec. 24, 1997) ( South Carolina Order)  3945. If it had the opportunity to do so, AT&T would demonstrate that this evidence is misleading,0*0*0* inaccurate and immaterial, and, in all events, would not cure BellSouths failure to demonstrate compliance with the competitive checklist. Yet, as the Commission recognized in both the Ameritech Michigan Order and the South Carolina Order, under the expedited procedures governing section 271 applications, commenters do not have the practical ability to respond to evidence presented for the first time in the applicants reply comments. Allowing the applicant to introduce new information at the reply comment phase thus is unfair to "other parties," because it denies them a fair opportunity to respond to the information, and encourages applicants to "'game the system.'" Ameritech Michigan Order  52 (citation omitted); South Carolina Order  45. ` ` To avoid this problem here and equally important to deter future noncompliance with the Commissions rules, AT&T respectfully requests that the Commission strike BellSouth's improper material from the record. In the alternative, the Commission should disregard such material. ` `  %hh,28pp?Respectfully submitted, __________________________hh,28pp?_____________________________ Mark C. Rosenblum %hh,28pp?Mark E. Haddad Roy E. Hoffinger %hh,28pp?Michael J. Hunseder Stephen C. Garavito %hh,28pp?Sidley & Austin ` `  %hh,28pp?1722 Eye Street, N.W. X Its Attorneys` `  %hh,28pp?Washington, D.C. 20006 X ` `  %hh,28pp?(202) 7368000 AT&T Corp. 295 North Maple Ave.%hh,28pp?Counsel for AT&T Corp. Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 (908) 2213539 Dated: September 17, 1998Q%0*0*0* =  YK 1 EXHIBIT 1 ă 5=0*0*0*  Y 0 LIST OF BELLSOUTH'S EVIDENCE SUBMITTED IN VIOLATION  X OF THE COMMISSION'S RULES THAT THE COMMISSION SHOULD STRIKE ă Reply Brief: XX` ` p. 23 (evidence of availability of CSRs after July 9th)(#` XX` ` p. 32 (evidence of business rules that were provided after July 9th)(#` XX` ` p. 34 (separation of EDI flowthrough data; performance data for June and July that is not directly responsive)(#` XX` ` pp. 40, 67 (evidence of ADUF postdating July 9th)(#` XX` ` pp. 5658 (newly raised takings claim)(#` XX` ` p. 65 (performance data on cutover postdating July 9th)(#` XX` ` pp. 8283 (evidence and argument regarding resale restrictions that BellSouth should have anticipated and filed with original application)(#` XX` ` p. 87 (data on performance measures that postdate July 9th)(#` Milner Reply Aff.: XX` `  19 (performance data on loop cutovers postdating July 9th)(#` Stacy Reply OSS Aff.: XX` `  26 (evidence of availability of CSRs after July 9th)(#` XX` `  42 (evidence of business rules that were provided after July 9th)(#` XX` `  6264 (separation of EDI flowthrough data that BellSouth should have anticipated and filed with original application; reconfiguration of flowthrough data on reply; performance data for June and July that is not directly responsive)(#` Stacy Reply PM Aff.: XX` `  21 (explanation of CLEC errors that BellSouth should have anticipated and filed with original application; reconfiguration of flowthrough data on reply; performance data for June and July that is not directly responsive)(#` XX` ` Exhs. WNSPM Reply 4a4e (reconfiguration of flowthrough data on reply; performance data for June and July that is not directly responsive)(#` XX` ` Exhs. WNSPM Reply 5a, 5b (explanation of CLEC errors that BellSouth should have anticipated and filed with original application)(#` Varner Reply Aff.: XX` `  50, 51 (evidence and argument regarding resale restrictions that BellSouth should have anticipated and filed with original application)