NEWSReport No. MM 96-24 MASS MEDIA ACTION July 24, 1996 FCC DENIES PETITION TO DELETE NONCOMMERCIAL RESERVATION FOR WQEX(TV), CHANNEL *16, PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA The Comission has adopted a Memorandum Opinion and Order denying the "Petition to Delete Noncommercial Reservation" filed by WQED Pittsburgh, licensee of noncommercial educational television Stations WQED(TV), Channel *13 and WQEX(TV), Channel *16, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The Commission also denied the Petition to Revoke License of WQEX(TV) filed by Pittsburgh Educational Television, Inc. (PET). Pursuant to Pub. L. No. 104-134, WQED requested that the Commission amend Section 73.606 of its rules to delete the noncommercial reservation of Channel *16, the frequency on which WQEX(TV) operates, thus allowing WQED to assign the license to a commercial broadcaster. WQED proposed to use the proceeds to relieve its severe financial distress and create an endowment to enable WQED(TV) to produce new programming and make major fixed asset acquisitions. By Public Notice released June 26, 1996, the Commission invited interested persons to comment on WQED's petition. Applying the criteria in the statute, the Commission found that it was presented with strong competing public interest considerations. On the one hand, the Commission observed that WQED had demonstrated that is was in severe financial distress and that the sale of WQEX(TV) as a commercial station could afford it the means of resolving these difficulties. On the other hand, the FCC noted that the solution proposed by WQED, the dereservation and commercial sale of a noncommercial channel, was unprecedented -- the Commission has never dereserved noncommercial spectrum without providing a replacement channel -- and ran contrary to the Commission's longstanding goal of promoting the growth of public television. On balance, the Commission concluded that WQED had failed to make the compelling showing necessary to support an exception to the Commission's strongly held policy disfavoring dereservation of noncommercial educational channels. (over) - 2 - Specifically, the Commission found that the record does not establish that there exists a clear and present "threat to the public of losing or impairing local public broadcasting service," noting that WQED has acknowledged that it would not go dark if it were unable to sell Channel *16 to a commercial broadcaster. The Commission also stated that it could not find on the record before it that there is no need for a second noncommercial channel at Pittsburgh. While WQED asserted that it no longer required a second channel to provide educational progamming, the FCC noted that others, including PET, have expressed an interest in providing noncommercial educational programming on Channel *16. The Commission further stated that it did not believe that dereservation of Channel *16 was necessary to relieve the financial distress of WQED or to alleviate the threat that distress posed to noncommercial service in Pittsburgh. In particular, the FCC noted that WQED had entered an agreement with Cornerstone TeleVision, Inc. (Cornerstone), the licensee of commercial Channel 40, Greensburg, Pennsylvania, whereby, if approved by the Commission, WQED and Cornerstone would exchange channels, Cornerstone would operate on Channel *16 on a noncommercial educational basis and WQED would sell Channel 40 to a commercial broadcaster and split the proceeds of the sale with Cornerstone. This approach would apparently afford WQED significant financial relief, yet would avoid the dereservation of Channel *16 or any other reduction in the number of noncommercial channels allotted to Pittsburgh. While WQED argued that this channel exchange approach would result in WQED receiving smaller proceeds than from an outright sale of Channel *16, the Commission noted that WQED did not contend that the channel exchange would produce income inadequate to redress WQED's financial difficulties. Finally, the Commission noted that one of the public interest benefits which WQED advanced as favoring dereservation -- enhanced diversity and competition in the Pittsburgh market through the divestiture of Channel *16 to a commercial broadcaster -- will also be achieved if WQED were to implement its agreement with Cornerstone. The Commission noted that the Cornerstone agreement was not before it and that it was not prejudging any applications that might be filed based on that agreement. It stated, however, that it would promptly consider any further details or arguments WQED wished to make regarding its channel exchange arrangement with Cornerstone, or any applications which it wished to file implementing its agreement with Cornerstone. Action by the Commission July 24, 1996, by Memorandum Opinion and Order (FCC 96- 314). Chairman Hundt, Commissioner Ness issuing a separate statement; Commissioners Quello and Chong concurring in the result and issuing separate statements. All statements will be released with the text of the decision. - FCC - Mass Media contact: Bob Ratcliffe at (202) 418-2600. News Media contact: David Fiske at (202) 418-0500.