$//MO&O Dismissed, DA 94-1576//$ $/300.534 Carriage of local Commercial television signals/$ $/76.61 Disputes concerning carriage/$ Before the FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20554 DA-94-1576 In re: ) ) ) Complaint of John Wiegand against ) CSR-4179-M Post Newsweek Pacifica Cable TV, Inc. ) CA0925 ) ) Request for Enforcement ) MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER Adopted: December 20, 1994 Released: January 4, 1995 By the Cable Services Bureau: INTRODUCTION 1. On December 10, 1993, John P. Wiegand filed a "Complaint" against Post- Newsweek Pacific Cable Television TV, Inc. ("Post"), operator of a cable system serving Burlingame, California. Post filed an "Opposition to Complaint" on February 2, 1994, and a supplement to it on February 9, 1994. SUMMARY OF PLEADINGS 2. In his complaint, Mr. Wiegand alleges various violations of the Commission's rules committed by Post-Newsweek Pacific Cable TV, Inc (Post). In this proceeding, we limit our inquiry to alleged violations of the Commission's mandatory carriage rules. Mr. Wiegand contends that Post deleted station KMTP-TV (channel 32, Ind.) San Francisco, California on December 15, 1992, in violation of Section 5(c) of the 1992 Cable Act, and to the injury of Post's subscribers who were deprived of its educational and informational programming until Post restored its carriage about June 2, 1993. Additionally, Mr. Wiegand asserts that Post failed to commence carriage of Stations KPST-TV (Ind., Channel 66), Vallejo, California, and KFCB (Ind., Channel 42), Concord, California, thereby violating Section 4 of the 1992 Cable Act and depriving its subscribers of access to these two stations' programming. 3. In response, Post asks that the Commission dismiss Mr. Wiegand's complaint because under the 1992 Cable Act and the Commission's rules subscribers do not have standing to file complaints alleging violations of the Commission's signal carriage rules. In the alternative, Post argues that Mr. Wiegard's contentions are wrong in each of the areas he raises. Post states that it carried KMPT-TV when its prior call-sign was KQEC, but that the station changed its ownership, format, and call-sign on August 31, 1991, after which its signal became sporadic, and it often went dark with no prior notice. Therefore, Post discontinued carriage of the station in December 1992, but resumed its carriage on June 2, 1993, when KMPT-TV began broadcasting again on a regular schedule. With respect to the other two stations, Post again argues that Mr. Wiegand lacks standing to raise the issue for the reasons discussed previously, and that both KPST-TV and KFCB were notified by letter dated April 28, 1993, that they lacked the requisite signal quality to qualify as must-carry stations, and that their carriage could cause the system increased copyright liability. Since neither station has thus far proffered any indemnification or improved its signal quality, neither is currently entitled to mandatory carriage, according to Post. In this regard, Post notes that Mr. Wiegand was apparently unaware of the above correspondence between itself and the subject stations. Post asserts that this is why the 1992 Cable Act and the Commission's rules do not give standing to subscribers to file signal carriage complaints, but rather only the station who would be fully aware of the facts. DISCUSSION 4. Neither the 1992 Cable Act nor our rules give subscribers standing to file complaints before this Commission alleging violations of our signal carriage rules. Consequently we must dismiss the complaint filed by Mr. Wiegand with regard to Post- Newsweek Pacific cable TV, Inc.'s failure to carry Stations KMTP-TV, KPST-TV, and KFCB. ORDERING CLAUSES 5. In view of the foregoing, we find that grant of Mr. Wiegand's complaint is not in the public interest. 6. Accordingly, the "Complaint" (CSR-41790-M) filed December 10, 1993, by John Wiegand IS DISMISSED, pursuant to Section 615(j)(3) of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended (47 U.S.C. 535). This action is taken by the Cable Services Bureau, pursuant to Section 0.321 of the Commission's Rules. FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION William H. Johnson Deputy Chief, Cable Services Bureau